
Photo Credit: Unsplash/Getty Images
In Post 2, Aaron showed you how to find a facilitator worth getting excited about. Congrats! Now comes the part where you bring them home to meet the family.
If you work for an association, that family is your board. I’ll be honest: this is where I’ve seen plenty of good matches stall. You can find the perfect facilitator and still have to pass because the board heard “we want to spend money on a retreat” and stopped listening right there.
So let’s talk about how to make the introduction go well.
“The board” isn’t one audience. It’s at least three, and each one cares about something different.
You’ll probably have the same conversation three times with three different emphases. That may feel redundant, but it’s also how you avoid a surprise at the meeting when the vote happens.
Some boards don’t respond well to “we think this would be valuable.” They respond to cost, risk, and return, so translate.
Start with the hours. Say you’ve got fifteen people in a room for eight hours. That’s 120 hours of volunteer and senior staff leadership time, and it doesn’t count preparation or travel. The question isn’t only whether the facilitator’s fee is worth it. It’s whether you want 120 hours of your most valuable people used well or used loosely.
Then connect the fee to something the board already cares about:
You don’t need a spreadsheet with perfect numbers. You need a credible case that the fee is small next to what’s at stake.
Somebody will ask. It’s often someone smart and experienced, and it’s a fair question. Sometimes the answer really is yes. A low-stakes conversation among people who trust each other doesn’t always need an outsider.
But here’s what I’d ask in return. Who would run it? If it’s the CEO, they can’t also be a full participant, and the board loses that individual’s voice. If it’s the chair, they can’t argue for a position without losing their neutrality. If it’s another board member, everyone else wonders what stake that person has. Someone in the room always has to choose between steering and contributing, and the group pays for that choice.
A few other objections you’ll likely hear, with how I tend to answer them:
Not hiring someone feels free, but it isn’t. The same conversation ends up on the agenda for the third year in a row. The decision everyone keeps deferring gets made by default when a deadline arrives. Staff stop bringing big ideas to the board because they don’t expect them to go anywhere. Your best volunteers drift away, usually without telling you why.
Think about our three situations. In It’s Complicated, where two boards share a long history and little trust, the mistrust gets more expensive every month it goes unaddressed. In a Whirlwind Romance, such as a sudden CEO departure, waiting a week can mean a reactive decision that someone has to live with for years. Even in the Comfortable Long-Term Match, a routine plan refresh, putting it off means the board is steering by an old map.
A key point here: Inaction costs something, but so does a bad hire, and your board will notice if you only talk about one side of that equation.
I’ve seen this pattern more times than I can count. Staff do the legwork, choose the facilitator, get a signature, and announce it to the board as a done deal. Then, on the day of the session, a board member says, “I didn’t know we were doing this,” and sits there with their arms crossed. You’ve lost a participant before the first sticky note.
A few ways to avoid it:
The goal is for every board member to answer three questions in roughly the same way: Why are we doing this? Who is this person? What happens afterward? If you ask five of them and get five different answers, you aren’t done.
A one-page overview helps. Include the purpose, the outcomes you’re after, the facilitator’s role, the board’s role, the date and place, and what you expect people to do beforehand. Send it to everyone and ask the chair to mention it at a meeting.
This plays out differently in each of our cases. In It’s Complicated, both boards need to see the facilitator as acceptable to each side, which usually means they both had a voice in choosing. In the Comfortable Long-Term Match, buy-in comes easily but engagement can run thin, so be clear about what you’re asking people to bring. In a Whirlwind Romance, you won’t have time for a full process, so lean on the chair, speak with one voice, and say plainly what you know and what you don’t.
Finding the right facilitator is half the job. Getting your board to want that facilitator is the other half. Talk to the chair first, speak the board’s language, answer the “why not do it ourselves” question honestly, and make sure everyone is dating the same person before the first session.
Next up: Aaron takes on “Defining the Relationship,” how to set up the engagement so everyone knows what they’ve signed up for.
---
Tara Puckey, MBA, FASAE, CAE, CMP, is President & CEO of RTDNA and the RTDNA Foundation, founder of GrayRails Consulting, and a facilitator who helps associations govern wisely, lead with courage, and build teams that last.